-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 253
Open
Description
Problem
This project ships a .vscode/tasks.json that references the $esbuild-watch problem matcher:
"problemMatcher": "$esbuild-watch"However, $esbuild-watch is not a built-in VS Code problem matcher and is only available when the esbuild-problem-matchers extension is installed.
When the extension is not installed, VS Code fails to activate tasks entirely with the following error:
Activating task providers
npm Error: Invalid problemMatcher reference: $esbuild-watch
This prevents users from running or testing tasks at all.
Why this is an issue
- esbuild itself runs correctly without any VS Code extension
- problemMatchers are a UX feature, not a runtime requirement
- however, VS Code treats unknown problemMatchers as a hard error
- as a result, tasks become unusable unless a specific extension is installed
This effectively makes the extension a mandatory dependency, even though it should be optional.
Expected behavior
One of the following:
- tasks should still run even if the problemMatcher is unavailable, or
- the tasks configuration should not hard-depend on external problemMatchers, or
- VS Code should support optional / soft problemMatcher references
Suggested solutions
- Provide tasks without external problemMatchers by default
- Document the problemMatcher as optional
- Or provide separate tasks for enhanced UX when the extension is installed
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels