Disable default-features for http-types#63
Conversation
|
That isn't true, we re-export some things (e.g. I suspect we could change this without anyone noticing but we should probably be careful. |
|
Good catch, thank you. It looks like the main issue there would be things like (In theory, someone could rely on |
265076d to
8e2bd38
Compare
|
@Fishrock123 Does this seem more reasonable? I think we can make this change without a semver-major bump. |
|
Not sure what's causing the test failure. It looks like it happens on latest main, without this change; perhaps something changed elsewhere in the ecosystem that broke the http-client build. EDIT: Ah, it's http-rs/tide#787 . |
|
@joshtriplett Could you rebase? |
http-client doesn't need the cookie feature. http-client also doesn't *directly* use the fs feature, but it re-exports http_types::Body and people might be relying on Body::from_file, so depend on the fs feature for compatibility.
8e2bd38 to
250ce32
Compare
|
@Fishrock123 Done. |
|
@joshtriplett If we release this, is cargo smart enough to not upgrade someone to this version if they are pinning to a previous http-types for some reason? |
|
@Fishrock123 Cargo doesn't allow multiple compatible versions of the same crate in one dependency tree. If you're pinning an older http-types, you can't end up with a newer http-client that needs a newer http-types. (I don't know to what degree cargo's version resolution will decide to use an older http-client and to what degree it'll throw up its hands and say "nope, incompatible".) |
|
Checking back on this: would it be possible to merge this to allow dropping cookie crates from projects that don't need them? |
|
Bumping a major here likely means bumping a major in surf, which I'd like to avoid until I have to for http-types 3.0 if possible. |
|
Is there a major milestone waiting to get to http-types 3.0? Similarly I'm trying to get rid of dependencies keeping things as light as possible and the latest http-types helps a bit changing the rand dependency that I wont be needing |
|
@Fishrock123 As far as I can tell, now that this change no longer omits the |
http-client doesn't use any of the default features.